Mary Bengford American Family Insurance - Greeley, Colorado

Lacy H.

Mary was so amazing to work with. We have a lot of trailers, outbuildings, vehicles, equipment, and livestock so it took a lot of work to get us the best policy. But she made it easy for me and always worked within my schedule. I would recommend her 100%. And the best part is she saved me hundreds of dollars a MONTH on our auto insurance.

Shante M.

After a terrible experience with our previous insurance company, we knew it was time to make a change. That’s when we found Mary, and wow—what a breath of fresh air! From the start, she was incredibly kind, patient, and knowledgeable, taking the time to walk us through all our options for our home and four vehicles.

Her quote for our home came in lower than what we had been paying, though still higher than we had hoped. But instead of just pushing us to sign with her, Mary did something that truly set her apart—she recommended another company that might be able to offer us a better rate. That level of honesty and integrity is so rare in this industry. She wasn’t just looking to make a sale; she was looking out for us.

In the end, her quote still beat our previous company’s rates, and we couldn’t be more grateful for her guidance. Mary is not just an insurance agent—she’s a trusted advisor. If you want someone who genuinely cares about your best interests, look no further. I will recommend her to everyone!

Colleen C.

I had Mary do a review of my current insurance, hoping she could beat it so I could work with her because she is honestly a great person. She very honestly told me where I should add coverage and what the differences would be with her policy, but in the end told me to stay put and we would review again next renewal cycle. That kind of honesty and integrity is rare these days. I have known her for years and would expect her customer service to be top notch as well. I think you can't go wrong using Mary for your insurance needs!

MARKLEY D. A.

Mary was incredibly helpful in guiding me through my insurance needs, taking the time to understand my specific situation and recommending the best options for my family. Her personalized approach made the entire process, smooth and stress-free.

Kayla W.

Mary was so thorough with her review of our home and auto policies! She made insurance make sense, which I’ve always struggled with. She knows her stuff and provided great insight to what coverage our family should have. She’s a great resource for all your insurance needs!

Maria G.

Mary is an amazing broker, with personalized and responsive service. She has helped our family broker for better coverage (home and auto with young drivers) and more resonable prices twice now. Give her a call and let her take the stress out of insurance shopping.

Laura M.

Mary was extremely knowledgeable and helpful when it came getting a quote for our new home. She got back to us quickly and went above and beyond finding out details about our new home that would customize our insurance. Loved working with her and highly recommend her to family and friends!

Jody M.

Mary has diligently worked to find insurance solutions for several of our family members. She has always been professional, patient, and kind. Mary either has an answer for the many questions I asked or would dig deep to help me find the correct answers. Additionally, she has high ethical standards and works to do what is best for the client. Mary is a standout professional in her field. If you need insurance, be sure to give her the opportunity to quote a policy for you!