Cincinnatus Insurance LLC - Cincinnati, Ohio

Elizabeth B.

I was recommended Nick with Cincinnatus by my lender and I couldn’t be happier with my decision to leave State Farm. The whole process of picking my new auto and home policies was very smooth and Nick created a 10 min video to help explain the different policies to me which was beyond helpful. He did not once try to upsell me unnecessarily which was a stark contrast to my previous experience with insurance agents. He was also extremely efficient and had everything done within 24 hours, again completely different than my previous agency which was a painfully slow and drawn out process. He was able to find us the best deal with insurance in our area and I am super happy with the price that he was able to get us. Would 100% recommend Cincinnatus to others looking to make a change in insurance!

Mandy S.

My experience working with Rachael was exceptional. She was prompt at answering all of our questions and walking us through the process. She was friendly and knowledgeable, taking us step by step through the process of transitioning providers once we decided to move forward. Rates were competitive to others we reviewed and they were able to save us money in specific areas which allowed us to make the change. I highly recommend them to anyone searching for insurance services.”

Michael W.

The easiest part of buying our home!

We sent Nick some basic info. He sent back a video laying out two options, both of which were highly competitive price-wise but had different characteristics. I reviewed and replied after I had some time to think it over.

Answered my questions on canceling my old auto insurance and bundling. Prompt, clear communicator. Worked well with the mortgage people.

Leah C.

Nick was fantastic to work with and I highly recommend using his company for your insurance needs. The process was quick and easy but felt comprehensive and I got all my questions answered. Best part - I saved a lot of money, and ended up with better coverage than I had before!

Abby D.

Everyone knows that adulting sucks. However, the people you have in your corner absolutely matter. Cincinnatus Insurance has been our carrier for going on a decade and the staff and our agent have proven time and time again that they are here for their clients. Nick Thalhammer especially has led a great team to provide some of the best customer service to the Cincinnatus Insurance clients he serves. That dedication and subject matter expertise is exactly what you need as you navigate through claims processes with your carrier.

Fisher O.

Excellent experience! I worked with Nick to get a new home insurance policy and auto insurance bundle. I appreciated the video he sent explaining the policy options. We ended up saving 28% on our auto insurance, and better coverage than our previous insurance. Thanks again Nick!

James S.

Nick was great to work with. Fast and efficient with the quoting process and addressed my concerns and questions easily and made me feel comfortable about the insurance process. Great and professional service from introduction to through the binding process.

Vilma D.

Auto and Home Insurance
Nick was an absolute pleasure to negotiate with. He is professional, diligent, and extremely pleasant to work with. From start to finish, the experience with him has been nothing short of wonderful. Highly recommend!